Book Review

Book Review: “Good Girl, Bad Blood” by Holly Jackson

Sometimes, the truth is closer than you think. Sometimes, it’s right under your nose. But the problem with the truth is that it’s also relentless. Once you know it, you can’t unknow it. It’s always there, like an itch you can’t scratch.

Holly Jackson

This chilling quote from Holly Jackson’s “Good Girl, Bad Blood” perfectly sets the tone for the thrilling ride you’re about to embark on. As the highly anticipated sequel to the bestseller “A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder,” this book promises to deliver another dose of gripping suspense and clever twists.

Overview of the Book Review

In “Good Girl, Bad Blood,” we return to the world of Pip Fitz-Amobi, a high school senior who has already earned a reputation as a young detective. After solving one murder case in her small town of Little Kilton, Pip decides to put her sleuthing days behind her and focus on her future.

But when another person goes missing, and the police refuse to investigate, Pip is drawn back into the dangerous world of secrets and lies. This time, the stakes are even higher, and Pip must navigate a maze of clues and red herrings to uncover the truth.

How I Picture Pippa | Credit: Pinterest

Why It’s Compelling

Holly Jackson masterfully blends elements of young adult fiction, mystery, and crime thriller genres in this fast-paced and compelling story. Through Pip’s perspective, we experience the tension, fear, and determination that drive her quest for justice. Whether you’re a fan of detective stories or simply love a good mystery, “Good Girl, Bad Blood” will keep you on the edge of your seat from start to finish.

Author Background

Holly Jackson, the brilliant mind behind “Good Girl, Bad Blood,” is a British author known for her knack for crafting compelling and intricate mystery novels. Born in 1992 in Buckinghamshire, England, Jackson developed a passion for storytelling at a young age. She studied English at the University of Nottingham, where her love for literature and writing deepened.

Jackson’s debut novel, “A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder,” was released in 2019 and quickly garnered critical acclaim, earning her a place among the top contemporary young adult authors. The book’s success can be attributed to her unique ability to blend elements of traditional detective fiction with modern, relatable characters and situations. Her storytelling is characterized by meticulous plotting, rich character development, and an ever-present sense of suspense.

With “Good Girl, Bad Blood,” Jackson continues to build on the success of her debut, further establishing her reputation as a master of the young adult mystery genre. Her works have not only captivated readers but also inspired a new generation of mystery enthusiasts. Beyond her novels, Jackson is known for engaging with her readers on social media, offering insights into her writing process and sharing updates about her upcoming projects. Her dedication to her craft and her fans is evident in every page she writes.

Plot Analysis

“Good Girl, Bad Blood” picks up where “A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder” left off, thrusting us back into the life of Pip Fitz-Amobi. After solving her first big case, Pip is determined to move on and leave her amateur sleuthing behind. However, her plans are derailed when a local teenager, Jamie Reynolds, goes missing. With the police unwilling to investigate, Pip is compelled to step in once again.

How I Picture Ravi Singh | Credit: Pinterest

Structure and Pacing

The book is structured in a way that keeps the reader engaged from start to finish. Jackson uses a combination of narrative storytelling, mixed media such as transcripts and blog posts, and Pip’s own investigative notes to create a multifaceted and immersive reading experience. The pacing is brisk, with each chapter ending on a note that urges you to keep turning the pages.

As Pip delves deeper into Jamie’s disappearance, she uncovers a web of secrets and lies that threaten to unravel the very fabric of her small town. Major plot twists are expertly woven into the story, each one more shocking than the last. These twists are not just for shock value; they significantly impact the trajectory of the story and the development of the characters, particularly Pip, who finds herself questioning her own values and beliefs.

Investigation Process

One of the standout elements of the plot is how Jackson handles the investigation process. Pip’s methods are logical and detailed, reflecting a realistic portrayal of how an amateur detective might tackle such a complex case. The tension builds steadily as Pip gets closer to the truth, leading to a climax that is both satisfying and thought-provoking.

“Good Girl, Bad Blood” is a well-structured and meticulously plotted mystery that keeps readers on their toes. Jackson’s skillful storytelling and ability to create suspense make this book a worthy sequel that lives up to the high standards set by its predecessor.

Themes and Messages

“Good Girl, Bad Blood” explores several central themes that add depth and complexity to its gripping mystery plot. One of the most prominent themes is the pursuit of truth and justice. Pip Fitz-Amobi’s relentless determination to uncover the truth about Jamie Reynolds’ disappearance highlights the importance of seeking justice, even when faced with obstacles and resistance. This theme resonates throughout the book, emphasizing that the quest for justice often requires courage, resilience, and a willingness to confront uncomfortable truths.

Secrets and Lies

Another key theme is the impact of secrets and lies. Jackson skillfully demonstrates how hidden truths can fester and lead to devastating consequences. As Pip uncovers layers of deception within her community, readers are reminded of the far-reaching effects of dishonesty and the importance of transparency. This theme is particularly relevant in a world where information can be easily manipulated, and it underscores the value of integrity and honesty.

Community Impact

The book also delves into the theme of community and the interconnectedness of people’s lives. Pip’s investigation reveals how the actions and decisions of individuals can ripple through a community, affecting everyone in unexpected ways. This theme is a reminder of the responsibility we have towards one another and the impact we can have on those around us.

Personal Evaluation

From the very first page, I was hooked on “Good Girl, Bad Blood.” Already familiar with Pip Fitz-Amobi and the vibrant cast of characters from “A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder,” diving back into their world felt like revisiting old friends. Holly Jackson’s ability to create such relatable and engaging characters is one of the book’s greatest strengths.

P.S: Picture created by me | Inspiration – Pinterest

One of the standout aspects of this novel is its pacing. It’s incredibly fast-paced, making it nearly impossible to put down. Each chapter ends with a cliffhanger, and the narrative drive keeps you on the edge of your seat. This book is definitely worth a 5-star rating for its ability to maintain such a high level of suspense throughout.

The plot is another area where Jackson truly shines. The story is meticulously constructed, with every detail and clue carefully placed to lead to a satisfying and surprising conclusion. The twists and turns kept coming, and I can honestly say I guessed none of them. Each revelation was more shocking than the last, making for an exhilarating reading experience.

Character development is handled exceptionally well. Pip’s evolution from an amateur detective to a more seasoned investigator is both believable and compelling. Her struggles, doubts, and growth are portrayed with such realism that you can’t help but root for her. The supporting characters also feel fully fleshed out, adding depth and richness to the story.

While the book has many strengths, if I had to point out a minor weakness, it would be that some subplots could have been explored more deeply. However, this doesn’t detract significantly from the overall enjoyment of the book.

One particularly memorable moment was Pip’s confrontation with the main antagonist. The tension was palpable, and the stakes felt incredibly high. This scene encapsulated the book’s ability to blend action, emotion, and suspense seamlessly.


Overall, “Good Girl, Bad Blood” is an outstanding sequel that not only lives up to the high expectations set by “A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder” but also surpasses them. Holly Jackson masterfully weaves together a compelling plot, believable characters, and relentless suspense to create a book that is both thrilling and thought-provoking.

I wholeheartedly recommend this book to fans of mystery and crime novels, especially those who enjoy young adult fiction with a strong, resourceful protagonist. It’s also perfect for readers who appreciate well-constructed plots and unexpected twists that keep them guessing until the very end.

For its gripping narrative, intricate plotting, and superb character development, I give “Good Girl, Bad Blood” a solid 5-star rating. Jackson’s ability to maintain a high level of suspense while delving into deeper themes and delivering a satisfying conclusion makes this book a standout read.

I encourage readers to pick up this book and experience the thrill of Pip’s latest investigation for themselves. Once you’ve read it, share your thoughts and join the discussion—I’d love to hear what you think!

Additional Resources

If you enjoyed “Good Girl, Bad Blood,” here are some related books and further reading suggestions:

A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder” by Holly Jackson – If you haven’t read the first book in the series, start here to fully appreciate Pip’s journey.
One of Us Is Lying” by Karen M. McManus – A thrilling mystery with a diverse cast of characters and plenty of twists.
The Naturals” by Jennifer Lynn Barnes – A young adult series featuring a group of teens with special skills who help the FBI solve crimes.

Questions to ponder or discuss:

How do you think Pip’s character has evolved from the first book to this one?
What do you think are the most important qualities of a good detective?
How do the themes of truth and justice play out in your own life or community?

Dive into “Good Girl, Bad Blood,” share your thoughts, and let’s keep the conversation going!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *